T Riepert1, F Glenewinkel, R Urschbach. 1. Institut für Rechtsmedizin, Johannes-Gutenberg-Universität Mainz. Thomas.Riepert@medizin.uni-koeln.de
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Physicians frequently have to face an investigation of their work from a judicial point of view. Due to these proceedings the number of cases when they are reproached with malpractice is increasing. CASE REPORT: We report the rare case of a 76-year-old female patient who fell from a 68 cm high couch after a sedative was applied during gastroscopical examination. She died 24 hours after the incident. Forensic necropsy revealed a delayed aortic rupture as the cause of death. The preliminary proceedings against the physician involved for culpable homicide by criminal negligence were suspended after he paid a fine. The possible legal consequences under German law for physicians involved in such cases are discussed as well as strategies to avoid them. CONCLUSION: Physicians who are under investigation for malpractice should act carefully. They are advised to seek professional help at an early stage of preliminary proceedings. A public trial should be avoided if possible.
BACKGROUND: Physicians frequently have to face an investigation of their work from a judicial point of view. Due to these proceedings the number of cases when they are reproached with malpractice is increasing. CASE REPORT: We report the rare case of a 76-year-old female patient who fell from a 68 cm high couch after a sedative was applied during gastroscopical examination. She died 24 hours after the incident. Forensic necropsy revealed a delayed aortic rupture as the cause of death. The preliminary proceedings against the physician involved for culpable homicide by criminal negligence were suspended after he paid a fine. The possible legal consequences under German law for physicians involved in such cases are discussed as well as strategies to avoid them. CONCLUSION: Physicians who are under investigation for malpractice should act carefully. They are advised to seek professional help at an early stage of preliminary proceedings. A public trial should be avoided if possible.