PURPOSE OF THE STUDY: The aim of our work was to study X-rays showing osteolysis after 5 years and more in 122 prosthesis and to try and assess such complication, often described in the United States but seldom in Europ. MATERIAL: We are dealing here with 122 retaining posterior cruciate ligament, mostly cementless prothesis implanted between 1985 and 1992 84 chromium-cobalt prosthesis (PCA and Themis) implanted in 34 males and 88 females with an average age of 67 (45-81), 87,7 p. 100 had femoral cementless components and 70 p. 100 tibial cementless components. METHODS: All patients were examined and had X-rays at an average of 6,9 years. Specially considered were X-rays showing a possible osteolysis. We looked for possible complication (external laxity, anterior femoral dislocation and polyethylene wear), assessment of the mechanical axis and for clinical results (Hungerford score) RESULTS: Revisions: 19 arthroplasties were revised for PE wear tibial loosening metallosis or patella problems The postoperative score according to Hungerford was 84,5 p. 100 for PCA prosthese and 87 p.100 for the Themis. On the X-rays were only few osteolysis to be found: 9 cases (7,3 p. 100). For the PCA series: 3 femoral osteolysis, 1 tibial at 12 years, and one patellar osteolysis. For the Themis series: no femoral osteolysis, 3 tibial and one patellar osteolysis. Osteolysis are apparent on X-rays in profile for the femur and the patella, and in both profile and frontal X-rays for the tibia. Clinicaly 4 osteolysis really asymptomatic were not re-operated. 5 were revised: one 11 years later for femoral and tibial loosening, two for a patellar loosening, the other two patients had to be reoperated on for metallism (titanium's femoral component) and for those two instances osteolysis were discovered during the complication. DISCUSSION: Osteolysis after TKA appears unusual in our experience without bearing on frequency finded by american authors with a lesser follow-up (Engh 11,1 p. 100 after 4,5y, Peters 16 p. 100 after 2,9 y, Robinson 9,18 p. 100 after 4,6 y). American litteratur analysis shows that the important number of osteolysis is due to: - either to dual-metal using (Co-Cr component with Titanium screws for exemple), - or bad quality of polyethylene (compressed), - or a bad design of former prosthesis. CONCLUSION: Interface illness, linked to the production of wear debris, osteolysis after total knee arthroplasty is rarer than after a hip one, probably because size of debris is different, larger in knee than in hip. It is likely that the improvement of PE quality, design of prosthesis, as well as a better knowledge of osteolysis mechanism will allow to delay this complication wich is in a long term ineluctable.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY: The aim of our work was to study X-rays showing osteolysis after 5 years and more in 122 prosthesis and to try and assess such complication, often described in the United States but seldom in Europ. MATERIAL: We are dealing here with 122 retaining posterior cruciate ligament, mostly cementless prothesis implanted between 1985 and 1992 84 chromium-cobalt prosthesis (PCA and Themis) implanted in 34 males and 88 females with an average age of 67 (45-81), 87,7 p. 100 had femoral cementless components and 70 p. 100 tibial cementless components. METHODS: All patients were examined and had X-rays at an average of 6,9 years. Specially considered were X-rays showing a possible osteolysis. We looked for possible complication (external laxity, anterior femoral dislocation and polyethylene wear), assessment of the mechanical axis and for clinical results (Hungerford score) RESULTS: Revisions: 19 arthroplasties were revised for PE wear tibial loosening metallosis or patella problems The postoperative score according to Hungerford was 84,5 p. 100 for PCA prosthese and 87 p.100 for the Themis. On the X-rays were only few osteolysis to be found: 9 cases (7,3 p. 100). For the PCA series: 3 femoral osteolysis, 1 tibial at 12 years, and one patellar osteolysis. For the Themis series: no femoral osteolysis, 3 tibial and one patellar osteolysis. Osteolysis are apparent on X-rays in profile for the femur and the patella, and in both profile and frontal X-rays for the tibia. Clinicaly 4 osteolysis really asymptomatic were not re-operated. 5 were revised: one 11 years later for femoral and tibial loosening, two for a patellar loosening, the other two patients had to be reoperated on for metallism (titanium's femoral component) and for those two instances osteolysis were discovered during the complication. DISCUSSION: Osteolysis after TKA appears unusual in our experience without bearing on frequency finded by american authors with a lesser follow-up (Engh 11,1 p. 100 after 4,5y, Peters 16 p. 100 after 2,9 y, Robinson 9,18 p. 100 after 4,6 y). American litteratur analysis shows that the important number of osteolysis is due to: - either to dual-metal using (Co-Cr component with Titanium screws for exemple), - or bad quality of polyethylene (compressed), - or a bad design of former prosthesis. CONCLUSION: Interface illness, linked to the production of wear debris, osteolysis after total knee arthroplasty is rarer than after a hip one, probably because size of debris is different, larger in knee than in hip. It is likely that the improvement of PE quality, design of prosthesis, as well as a better knowledge of osteolysis mechanism will allow to delay this complication wich is in a long term ineluctable.