OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the quality of the medical certification of deaths of 10-49 year-old women, resident in the Southern region of the city of S. Paulo METHODS: The Puffer methodology was utilized to investigate the causes of death of all 10-49 year-old women, resident in the region, and deceased in the year 1989 (664 deaths in the total). The main causes of death in the original death certificates and the "new" causes of death arisen from the research were compared. The sensitivity and the kappa index were calculated. RESULTS: In some chapters of the International Classification of Diseases and Causes of Death, 9th Revision (CID-9), a high sensitivity was found: "Diseases of the Circulatory System" (91.9%), "Neoplasms" (89.7%) and "External Causes" (84.1 %). In some others, a very low sensitivity was found. The chapter "Mental Illnesses", with a 34.3 percent sensitivity only, must be mentioned. From 11 deaths originally classified in this chapter, 32 cases were found. In most of these "new" cases, the main cause of death was found to be alcoholism. The chapter "Complications of Pregnancy, Delivery and the Puerperium", also showed a low sensitivity (44.9%). The kappa index was found to be 0.63, which indicated a regular concordance. DISCUSSION: The quality of the medical certification of causes of death is still unsatisfactory in the studied area. This poor quality may affect negatively the interventions in the area of women's health, masking the severity of important problems
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the quality of the medical certification of deaths of 10-49 year-old women, resident in the Southern region of the city of S. Paulo METHODS: The Puffer methodology was utilized to investigate the causes of death of all 10-49 year-old women, resident in the region, and deceased in the year 1989 (664 deaths in the total). The main causes of death in the original death certificates and the "new" causes of death arisen from the research were compared. The sensitivity and the kappa index were calculated. RESULTS: In some chapters of the International Classification of Diseases and Causes of Death, 9th Revision (CID-9), a high sensitivity was found: "Diseases of the Circulatory System" (91.9%), "Neoplasms" (89.7%) and "External Causes" (84.1 %). In some others, a very low sensitivity was found. The chapter "Mental Illnesses", with a 34.3 percent sensitivity only, must be mentioned. From 11 deaths originally classified in this chapter, 32 cases were found. In most of these "new" cases, the main cause of death was found to be alcoholism. The chapter "Complications of Pregnancy, Delivery and the Puerperium", also showed a low sensitivity (44.9%). The kappa index was found to be 0.63, which indicated a regular concordance. DISCUSSION: The quality of the medical certification of causes of death is still unsatisfactory in the studied area. This poor quality may affect negatively the interventions in the area of women's health, masking the severity of important problems
Authors: Michelle L Bell; Marie S O'Neill; Nalini Ranjit; Victor H Borja-Aburto; Luis A Cifuentes; Nelson C Gouveia Journal: Int J Epidemiol Date: 2008-05-29 Impact factor: 7.196