Effect of muscle action and metabolic strain on oxidative metabolic responses in human skeletal muscle.

A recent report suggests that differences in aerobic capacity exist between concentric and eccentric muscle action in human muscle (T. W. Ryschon, M. D. Fowler, R. E. Wysong, A. R. Anthony, and R. S. Balaban. J. Appl. Physiol. 83: 867-874, 1997). This study compared oxidative response, in the form of phosphocreatine (PCr) resynthesis rates, with matched levels of metabolic strain (i.e., changes in ADP concentration or the free energy of ATP hydrolysis) in tibialis anterior muscle exercised with either muscle action in vivo (n = 7 subjects). Exercise was controlled and metabolic strain measured by a dynamometer and (31)P-magnetic resonance spectroscopy, respectively. Metabolic strain was varied to bring cytosolic ADP concentration up to 55 microM or decrease the free energy of ATP hydrolysis to -55 kJ/mol with no change in cytoplasmic pH. PCr resynthesis rates after exercise ranged from 31.9 to 462.5 and from 21.4 to 405.4 micromol PCr/s for concentric and eccentric action, respectively. PCr resynthesis rates as a function of metabolic strain were not significantly different between muscle actions (P > 0.40), suggesting that oxidative capacity is dependent on metabolic strain, not muscle action. Pooled data were found to more closely conform to previous biochemical measurements when a term for increasing oxidative capacity with metabolic strain was added to models of respiratory control.