The efficacy of collagen dermis membrane and fibrin on cultured epidermal graft using an athymic mouse model.

A human skin substitute consisting of human cultured keratinocytes, collagen dermis, and fibrin was evaluated in athymic mice. Eighty athymic mice were divided randomly into four groups. A 1.5x1.5-cm full-thickness wound defect was created on the back of each athymic mouse under anesthesia. These wounds were covered by sheets of cultured epidermal graft (group A), cultured epidermal graft with collagen dermis and fibrin (group B), cultured epidermal graft with collagen dermis (group C), or cultured epidermal graft with fibrin (group D). The grafts were secured and kept moist by specially designed saline gauze chambers. The take rates of the cultured graft with more than 50% of the wound covered were 65%, 15%, 50%, and 45% respectively. Group B had a significantly lower graft take rate, however the difference was not significant among groups A, C, and D. Light microscopy of biopsies of the grafted sites at 12 days showed complete epithelialization. The incidence of discharge from wound beds in groups A, B, C, and D was 0%, 15%, 15%, and 10% respectively. The results suggest that cultured cells are best grafted directly onto the wound bed or in combination with either a thin layer of collagen or fibrin but not both because the collagen dermal membrane and the fibrin together may impose too great a diffusion barrier for the cultured cell graft to become vascularized.