PURPOSE: To compare the analgesia produced by comparable doses of intra-articular (IA) morphine and fentanyl. METHODS:Sixty-nine healthy patients undergoingarthroscopic surgery received a standardized general anesthetic of 4 mg x kg(-1) thiopental and 2 microg x kg(-1) fentanyl followed by 2 mg x kg(-1) succinylcholine prior to tracheal intubation and controlled ventilation. Maintenance of anesthesia was achieved with N2O/O2 and isoflurane. At the conclusion of surgery intra-articular injection was: Group I (n=23) 50 microg fentanyl in 20 ml saline; Group II (n=24) 3 mg morphine in 20 ml saline; Group III (n=22) 20 ml saline. Pain scores at rest using a visual analogue scale were recorded by a separate blinded observer at one, two, four, and eight hours postoperatively. RESULTS:Pain scores at one, two, four, and eight hours were 36, 26.3, 20.9, and 12.8 vs 35.8, 33.8, 28.8, and 21.9 vs 70.5, 57.7, 58.4, and 53.6 for the IA-fentanyl, IA-morphine, and control groups respectively. Pain scores were greater at all times for Group III. Pain scores for Groups I and II were similar at one hour, but thereafter were less (P < 0.001) for the IA-fentanyl group. CONCLUSION: Better postoperative analgesia was achieved with 50 microg intraarticular fentanyl than with 3 mg intraarticular morphine.
RCT Entities:
PURPOSE: To compare the analgesia produced by comparable doses of intra-articular (IA) morphine and fentanyl. METHODS: Sixty-nine healthy patients undergoing arthroscopic surgery received a standardized general anesthetic of 4 mg x kg(-1) thiopental and 2 microg x kg(-1) fentanyl followed by 2 mg x kg(-1) succinylcholine prior to tracheal intubation and controlled ventilation. Maintenance of anesthesia was achieved with N2O/O2 and isoflurane. At the conclusion of surgery intra-articular injection was: Group I (n=23) 50 microg fentanyl in 20 ml saline; Group II (n=24) 3 mg morphine in 20 ml saline; Group III (n=22) 20 ml saline. Pain scores at rest using a visual analogue scale were recorded by a separate blinded observer at one, two, four, and eight hours postoperatively. RESULTS:Pain scores at one, two, four, and eight hours were 36, 26.3, 20.9, and 12.8 vs 35.8, 33.8, 28.8, and 21.9 vs 70.5, 57.7, 58.4, and 53.6 for the IA-fentanyl, IA-morphine, and control groups respectively. Pain scores were greater at all times for Group III. Pain scores for Groups I and II were similar at one hour, but thereafter were less (P < 0.001) for the IA-fentanyl group. CONCLUSION: Better postoperative analgesia was achieved with 50 microg intraarticular fentanyl than with 3 mg intraarticular morphine.