D C Watts1, A al Hindi. 1. Biomaterials Science Unit, University of Manchester Dental School, UK. david.watts@man.ac.uk
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: A resin-composite based on multi-acrylate monomers was to be evaluated for any differences in the setting shrinkage-strain kinetics relative to more conventional formulations based on di-methacrylate monomers. METHODS: Four resin-composites were examined for shrinkage-strain over time periods up to 60 min, from initial irradiation, using a 'bonded disk' measurement device. One material was evaluated with a standard and also a two-level (low to high) blue light irradiation regime. The test material (Solitaire), and the other two controls were studied under fixed-(normal) level irradiation by blue light. Measurements were made at 23 and 37 degrees C. RESULTS: The low-high light irradiation applied to one di-methacrylate composite led to a highly significant (p < 0.001) reduction in shrinkage-strain to a minimal level for the initial 0.2 min. The fixed-level irradiation with the acrylate-composite also led to a formally identical, but intrinsic 'soft-start' shrinkage-delay regime; significant at p < 0.001. Di-methacrylate composites under the same fixed-level light regime did not exhibit shrinkage delay. Both di-methacrylate and multi-acrylate composites exhibited increases in the range 18-29% in final equilibrium shrinkage-strain by increase of specimen temperature. SIGNIFICANCE: Reductions in the rate of initial shrinkage of light-cured restoratives may have clinical benefits for restoration bond-integrity nearly as important as reductions in the final equilibrium shrinkage-strain. This may be achieved either by special light irradiation regimes (low to high, or ramped) or in favourable cases by novel monomer-composite formulations and setting chemistry (e.g. Solitaire). The bonded disk shrinkage-strain measurement technique is suitable for the elucidation of such rapid kinetic and temperature-dependent events during photo-polymerisation setting processes.
OBJECTIVES: A resin-composite based on multi-acrylate monomers was to be evaluated for any differences in the setting shrinkage-strain kinetics relative to more conventional formulations based on di-methacrylate monomers. METHODS: Four resin-composites were examined for shrinkage-strain over time periods up to 60 min, from initial irradiation, using a 'bonded disk' measurement device. One material was evaluated with a standard and also a two-level (low to high) blue light irradiation regime. The test material (Solitaire), and the other two controls were studied under fixed-(normal) level irradiation by blue light. Measurements were made at 23 and 37 degrees C. RESULTS: The low-high light irradiation applied to one di-methacrylate composite led to a highly significant (p < 0.001) reduction in shrinkage-strain to a minimal level for the initial 0.2 min. The fixed-level irradiation with the acrylate-composite also led to a formally identical, but intrinsic 'soft-start' shrinkage-delay regime; significant at p < 0.001. Di-methacrylate composites under the same fixed-level light regime did not exhibit shrinkage delay. Both di-methacrylate and multi-acrylate composites exhibited increases in the range 18-29% in final equilibrium shrinkage-strain by increase of specimen temperature. SIGNIFICANCE: Reductions in the rate of initial shrinkage of light-cured restoratives may have clinical benefits for restoration bond-integrity nearly as important as reductions in the final equilibrium shrinkage-strain. This may be achieved either by special light irradiation regimes (low to high, or ramped) or in favourable cases by novel monomer-composite formulations and setting chemistry (e.g. Solitaire). The bonded disk shrinkage-strain measurement technique is suitable for the elucidation of such rapid kinetic and temperature-dependent events during photo-polymerisation setting processes.
Authors: Hockin H K Xu; Frederick C Eichmiller; Douglas T Smith; Gary E Schumacher; Anthony A Giuseppetti; Joseph M Antonucci Journal: J Mater Sci Mater Med Date: 2002-09 Impact factor: 3.896
Authors: Eduardo Moreira da Silva; Laiza Tatiana Poskus; José Guilherme Antunes Guimarães; Alexandre de Araújo Lima Barcellos; Carlos Eduardo Fellows Journal: J Mater Sci Mater Med Date: 2007-08-01 Impact factor: 3.896
Authors: Jiancheng Liu; Gregory D Howard; Steven H Lewis; Matthew D Barros; Jeffrey W Stansbury Journal: Eur Polym J Date: 2012-11 Impact factor: 4.598