BACKGROUND: An increasing number of case reports indicate a superior therapeutic response of catatonialike symptoms, such as severe psychomotor disturbance and mutism, associated with psychiatric disorder to the benzodiazepine lorazepam (LO). Equivocal results, however, are also reported with regard to other benzodiazepines for the treatment of this syndrome. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of LO and oxazepam (OX), benzodiazepines with comparable pharmacokinetics, on psychomotor retardation and mutism associated with psychiatric disorder. METHODS:Twenty-one hospitalizedpatients with severe psychomotor retardation and mutism were treated with 2 mg LO and 60 mg OX in a double-blind crossover study design. RESULTS: Both benzodiazepines significantly reduced psychomotor symptoms. When administered for the first time, 4 of 7 patients with LO and 6 of 10 patients with OX improved at least 50% on visual analog scale (VAS) rating. Reduction in symptoms was significant with LO and OX treatment on either day of treatment. The second time, however, LO was significantly better compared with OX in alleviating the target symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: Both OX and LO are effective for the treatment of psychomotor retardation. Thus, the beneficial effect of LO on psychomotor retardation and mutism is not a unique pharmacodynamic property but more likely due to its pharmacokinetic profile. The differential effect of the two benzodiazepines on the second day of treatment warrants further clarification. Several hypotheses are evaluated.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: An increasing number of case reports indicate a superior therapeutic response of catatonialike symptoms, such as severe psychomotor disturbance and mutism, associated with psychiatric disorder to the benzodiazepinelorazepam (LO). Equivocal results, however, are also reported with regard to other benzodiazepines for the treatment of this syndrome. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of LO and oxazepam (OX), benzodiazepines with comparable pharmacokinetics, on psychomotor retardation and mutism associated with psychiatric disorder. METHODS: Twenty-one hospitalized patients with severe psychomotor retardation and mutism were treated with 2 mg LO and 60 mg OX in a double-blind crossover study design. RESULTS: Both benzodiazepines significantly reduced psychomotor symptoms. When administered for the first time, 4 of 7 patients with LO and 6 of 10 patients with OX improved at least 50% on visual analog scale (VAS) rating. Reduction in symptoms was significant with LO and OX treatment on either day of treatment. The second time, however, LO was significantly better compared with OX in alleviating the target symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: Both OX and LO are effective for the treatment of psychomotor retardation. Thus, the beneficial effect of LO on psychomotor retardation and mutism is not a unique pharmacodynamic property but more likely due to its pharmacokinetic profile. The differential effect of the two benzodiazepines on the second day of treatment warrants further clarification. Several hypotheses are evaluated.
Authors: Pascal Sienaert; Dirk M Dhossche; Davy Vancampfort; Marc De Hert; Gábor Gazdag Journal: Front Psychiatry Date: 2014-12-09 Impact factor: 4.157