S Parker1, J Campbell, C Ribble, A Gajadhar. 1. Department of Herd Medicine and Theriogenology, Western College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To compare sensitivity for diagnosing Tritrichomonas foetus infection in bulls using 2 sampling tools and to calculate negative predictive values for infection. DESIGN: Randomized clinical trial. ANIMALS: 30 Bos taurus bulls naturally or experimentally infected with T foetus. PROCEDURE: Preputial scrapings were obtained once/wk for 6 weeks using an artificial insemination pipette and a metal brush; which tool was used first for each bull was randomly determined. Samples were collected first from the left side of the prepuce and then from the right side and placed in commercially available transport media chi 2 Values and confidence limits were adjusted for effect of clustering of results by bull. RESULTS: Significant differences in sensitivity of results were not found between samples collected using the brush or pipette. Using the pipette, sensitivity was estimated to be 91.6% (95% confidence interval, 84.3 to 95.7%); negative predictive values ranged from 41 to 99% for prevalence of infection of 90 to 5%, respectively. Sensitivity was 88.8% for first sample obtained and 96.1% for second sample obtained. CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Collection of preputial scrapings with an artificial insemination pipette or a metal brush and use of a commercially available culture system can provide a sensitive diagnostic test for T foetus infection in bulls. Calculated negative predictive values indicated that 1 or 2 tests would suffice in most clinical situations. For bulls from herds in which T foetus is endemic, 2 to 4 tests/bull may be required to ensure that each bull is not infected.
OBJECTIVE: To compare sensitivity for diagnosing Tritrichomonas foetus infection in bulls using 2 sampling tools and to calculate negative predictive values for infection. DESIGN: Randomized clinical trial. ANIMALS: 30 Bos taurus bulls naturally or experimentally infected with T foetus. PROCEDURE: Preputial scrapings were obtained once/wk for 6 weeks using an artificial insemination pipette and a metal brush; which tool was used first for each bull was randomly determined. Samples were collected first from the left side of the prepuce and then from the right side and placed in commercially available transport media chi 2 Values and confidence limits were adjusted for effect of clustering of results by bull. RESULTS: Significant differences in sensitivity of results were not found between samples collected using the brush or pipette. Using the pipette, sensitivity was estimated to be 91.6% (95% confidence interval, 84.3 to 95.7%); negative predictive values ranged from 41 to 99% for prevalence of infection of 90 to 5%, respectively. Sensitivity was 88.8% for first sample obtained and 96.1% for second sample obtained. CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Collection of preputial scrapings with an artificial insemination pipette or a metal brush and use of a commercially available culture system can provide a sensitive diagnostic test for T foetus infection in bulls. Calculated negative predictive values indicated that 1 or 2 tests would suffice in most clinical situations. For bulls from herds in which T foetus is endemic, 2 to 4 tests/bull may be required to ensure that each bull is not infected.
Authors: Alvaro García-Guerra; Cheryl L Waldner; Andrea Pellegrino; Nicole Macdonald; Bonnie Chaban; Janet E Hill; Steven H Hendrick Journal: Can J Vet Res Date: 2016-01 Impact factor: 1.310