BACKGROUND: The value of systematic lymphadenectomy has been a matter of great controversy for a long period of time. A recently published paper of a retrospective autopsy study generally doubts its therapeutic effectiveness, arguing that positive lymph nodes are nearly always associated with distant metastases. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between 1974 and 1993 1035 patients suffering from renal cell carcinoma with stages from cT 1 to 4, cM 0 were treated with curative intention. 51% underwent radical abdominal tumour nephrectomy with systematic lymphadenectomy (n = 531, group A). In 199 patients (19%, group B) only macroscopically suspect lymph nodes were removed surgically. All other patients underwent radical lumbar tumour nephrectomy without lymphadenectomy (n = 305, 29%, group C). RESULTS: Mean age of group A was 55.5 +/- 10 years, B 60.3 +/- 11 and C 66.5 +/- 11. Median follow-up for all groups was 115 +/- 63 months. Median amount of removed lymph nodes was 18 in group A, 6 in group B and 3 in group C. N-categories for each group were pN 1: 4%, 2%, 1%; pN 2: 7%, 5%, 1%; pN 3: 3%, 2, %, 1%; pN x: 0%, 35%, 67% respectively. Group A with systematic lymphadenectomy had the least favourable tumour stage overall. Nevertheless long-term survival of this group is more favourable with 57% +/- 6 when compared to group B with 50 +/- 12% and C with 44% +/- 9%. 20 (27%) of the 75 lymph node positive patients of group A who have been followed-up for more than 5 years are still alive. CONCLUSIONS: At least 4% of all patients benefit from extensive lymphadenectomy. This may only be a relatively small proven effect for the entire patient collective, but for a single lymph node positive patient this is an undoubtedly significant additional chance of survival especially when one notes that presently there is no curative adjuvant therapy.
BACKGROUND: The value of systematic lymphadenectomy has been a matter of great controversy for a long period of time. A recently published paper of a retrospective autopsy study generally doubts its therapeutic effectiveness, arguing that positive lymph nodes are nearly always associated with distant metastases. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between 1974 and 1993 1035 patients suffering from renal cell carcinoma with stages from cT 1 to 4, cM 0 were treated with curative intention. 51% underwent radical abdominal tumour nephrectomy with systematic lymphadenectomy (n = 531, group A). In 199 patients (19%, group B) only macroscopically suspect lymph nodes were removed surgically. All other patients underwent radical lumbar tumour nephrectomy without lymphadenectomy (n = 305, 29%, group C). RESULTS: Mean age of group A was 55.5 +/- 10 years, B 60.3 +/- 11 and C 66.5 +/- 11. Median follow-up for all groups was 115 +/- 63 months. Median amount of removed lymph nodes was 18 in group A, 6 in group B and 3 in group C. N-categories for each group were pN 1: 4%, 2%, 1%; pN 2: 7%, 5%, 1%; pN 3: 3%, 2, %, 1%; pN x: 0%, 35%, 67% respectively. Group A with systematic lymphadenectomy had the least favourable tumour stage overall. Nevertheless long-term survival of this group is more favourable with 57% +/- 6 when compared to group B with 50 +/- 12% and C with 44% +/- 9%. 20 (27%) of the 75 lymph node positive patients of group A who have been followed-up for more than 5 years are still alive. CONCLUSIONS: At least 4% of all patients benefit from extensive lymphadenectomy. This may only be a relatively small proven effect for the entire patient collective, but for a single lymph node positive patient this is an undoubtedly significant additional chance of survival especially when one notes that presently there is no curative adjuvant therapy.
Authors: Janine Bacic; Tao Liu; R Houston Thompson; Stephen A Boorjian; Bradley C Leibovich; Dragan Golijanin; Boris Gershman Journal: Urology Date: 2020-03-04 Impact factor: 2.649