M E Edginton1. 1. Department of Community Health, University of the Witwatersrand, Parktown, Johannesburg, South Africa. 081mee@chiron.wits.ac.za
Abstract
SETTING: A rural district of the Northern Province, South Africa. OBJECTIVES: To measure the effect of decentralisation of a tuberculosis service in a rural area on treatment outcomes. DESIGN: An intervention study that measured treatment outcomes of patients attending district clinics for tuberculosis treatment and compared these with outcomes of patients attending the district hospital. RESULTS: Over the 4-year period 1992-1995, 928 patients were admitted to the tuberculosis unit of the district hospital. In the initial pre-intervention phase, the best estimate of completed treatment for all 503 cases was 61%, and for 206 new smear-positive patients it was 67%. The intervention process established a tuberculosis control programme with directly observed treatment for all patients, and training and supervision of clinic staff. Ninety per cent of all patients had community-based supporters. For most patients, cure was not proven, but assuming success from completion of and proven adherence to treatment, successful outcomes for new smear-positive cases rose to 82% for decentralised (clinic) treatment, and 88% for those patients who lived in the district but attended the hospital for treatment. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that district clinics can achieve the same good results as the hospital. It is recommended that tuberculosis control needs a dedicated co-ordinator at district level to manage the necessary infrastructural and staff resources.
SETTING: A rural district of the Northern Province, South Africa. OBJECTIVES: To measure the effect of decentralisation of a tuberculosis service in a rural area on treatment outcomes. DESIGN: An intervention study that measured treatment outcomes of patients attending district clinics for tuberculosis treatment and compared these with outcomes of patients attending the district hospital. RESULTS: Over the 4-year period 1992-1995, 928 patients were admitted to the tuberculosis unit of the district hospital. In the initial pre-intervention phase, the best estimate of completed treatment for all 503 cases was 61%, and for 206 new smear-positive patients it was 67%. The intervention process established a tuberculosis control programme with directly observed treatment for all patients, and training and supervision of clinic staff. Ninety per cent of all patients had community-based supporters. For most patients, cure was not proven, but assuming success from completion of and proven adherence to treatment, successful outcomes for new smear-positive cases rose to 82% for decentralised (clinic) treatment, and 88% for those patients who lived in the district but attended the hospital for treatment. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that district clinics can achieve the same good results as the hospital. It is recommended that tuberculosis control needs a dedicated co-ordinator at district level to manage the necessary infrastructural and staff resources.
Authors: Anthony D Harries; Megan B Murray; Christie Y Jeon; Salah-Eddine Ottmani; Knut Lonnroth; Mauricio L Barreto; Nils Billo; Richard Brostrom; Ib Christian Bygbjerg; Susan Fisher-Hoch; Toru Mori; Kaushik Ramaiya; Gojka Roglic; Hanne Strandgaard; Nigel Unwin; Vijay Viswanathan; David Whiting; Anil Kapur Journal: Trop Med Int Health Date: 2010-04-12 Impact factor: 2.622