INTRODUCTION: High tibial osteotomy in varus knee has been performed for a long time. Several newer operation techniques have been established in recent years. We tested the primary stability of several of these techniques in vitro. MATERIAL AND METHODS: 10 human cadaveric fresh-frozen specimens were tested with a mean age of 61 years (range 50-72 years), and weight of 65 to 78 kg. The following implants were tested: One-third-tubular plate with cortical screw (AO, Synthes), blade plate with screws (Giebel's plate, Link), bone staples (osteotomy staples, Krackow staples, Smith & Nephew), external fixateur (Orthofix). The specimens were fixed in metal cylinders and then loaded in two different apparati: Shear forces were applied to the osteotomy site by hanging weights parallel to the osteotomy plane in a static-loading frame, and axial forces were applied by a materials testing machine (Zwick). Load displacement was recorded by inductive displacement transducers. RESULTS: The highest stability was achieved by the external fixateurs and the bone staples. Giebel's plate and the one third tubular plate were less stable. Receipt of the medial corticalis was decisive for primary stability of the implants. CONCLUSION: The clinical significance of the results is limited by the relevance of the protocol, which for practical reasons did not account for the soft tissue situation around the knee. Thus, primary stability of the tested devices was generally comparable as long as they were correctly implanted. It was found, that lateral distance of the osteotomized bone should not exceed 3 mm. If the medial cortical is sawed, another medial implant is necessary to ensure sufficient primary stability.
INTRODUCTION: High tibial osteotomy in varus knee has been performed for a long time. Several newer operation techniques have been established in recent years. We tested the primary stability of several of these techniques in vitro. MATERIAL AND METHODS: 10 human cadaveric fresh-frozen specimens were tested with a mean age of 61 years (range 50-72 years), and weight of 65 to 78 kg. The following implants were tested: One-third-tubular plate with cortical screw (AO, Synthes), blade plate with screws (Giebel's plate, Link), bone staples (osteotomy staples, Krackow staples, Smith & Nephew), external fixateur (Orthofix). The specimens were fixed in metal cylinders and then loaded in two different apparati: Shear forces were applied to the osteotomy site by hanging weights parallel to the osteotomy plane in a static-loading frame, and axial forces were applied by a materials testing machine (Zwick). Load displacement was recorded by inductive displacement transducers. RESULTS: The highest stability was achieved by the external fixateurs and the bone staples. Giebel's plate and the one third tubular plate were less stable. Receipt of the medial corticalis was decisive for primary stability of the implants. CONCLUSION: The clinical significance of the results is limited by the relevance of the protocol, which for practical reasons did not account for the soft tissue situation around the knee. Thus, primary stability of the tested devices was generally comparable as long as they were correctly implanted. It was found, that lateral distance of the osteotomized bone should not exceed 3 mm. If the medial cortical is sawed, another medial implant is necessary to ensure sufficient primary stability.