P W Kaplan1, D Genoud, T W Ho, P Jallon. 1. Johns Hopkins Bayview Medical Center, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD 21224, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To determine the factors affecting prognosis in alpha coma (AC). METHODS: Retrospective review of 36 study patients, 36 control coma patients matched for age and etiology, and meta-analysis of 335 cases in the world literature. RESULTS: Principal causes were cardiorespiratory arrest (CRA) (21 patients); infection, metabolic dysfunction, head trauma (3 each); and drugs, stroke and hypoxia (2 each). Outcome was predicated by EEG reactivity to noxious stimuli. Fourteen of the 15 patients with reactive EEGs, had measurable outcome, 8 awoke - all but two had etiologies other than CRA. Fourteen of 19 patients without EEG reactivity died; two had support discontinued and 3 awoke. Following CRA, 16/21 patients died and 3 had support discontinued. Only 3 patients made a good recovery - all with toxic or metabolic etiologies. Literature meta-analysis of 335 cases showed that overall, AC carried a poor prognosis (76% died). CRA (226 cases) had an 88% mortality; strokes (29 cases), a 90% mortality; hypoxia without cardiac arrest (28 cases), a 61% mortality; drug-induced AC (25 cases), an 8% mortality. CONCLUSIONS: Although the cause of AC largely predicts outcome, EEG reactivity in AC predicted survival: most patients with reactivity awoke; most of those without, died. Few survivors had meaningful recovery.
OBJECTIVE: To determine the factors affecting prognosis in alpha coma (AC). METHODS: Retrospective review of 36 study patients, 36 control comapatients matched for age and etiology, and meta-analysis of 335 cases in the world literature. RESULTS: Principal causes were cardiorespiratory arrest (CRA) (21 patients); infection, metabolic dysfunction, head trauma (3 each); and drugs, stroke and hypoxia (2 each). Outcome was predicated by EEG reactivity to noxious stimuli. Fourteen of the 15 patients with reactive EEGs, had measurable outcome, 8 awoke - all but two had etiologies other than CRA. Fourteen of 19 patients without EEG reactivity died; two had support discontinued and 3 awoke. Following CRA, 16/21 patients died and 3 had support discontinued. Only 3 patients made a good recovery - all with toxic or metabolic etiologies. Literature meta-analysis of 335 cases showed that overall, AC carried a poor prognosis (76% died). CRA (226 cases) had an 88% mortality; strokes (29 cases), a 90% mortality; hypoxia without cardiac arrest (28 cases), a 61% mortality; drug-induced AC (25 cases), an 8% mortality. CONCLUSIONS: Although the cause of AC largely predicts outcome, EEG reactivity in AC predicted survival: most patients with reactivity awoke; most of those without, died. Few survivors had meaningful recovery.
Authors: Jan Claassen; Lawrence J Hirsch; Jennifer A Frontera; Andres Fernandez; Michael Schmidt; Gregory Kapinos; John Wittman; E Sander Connolly; Ronald G Emerson; Stephan A Mayer Journal: Neurocrit Care Date: 2006 Impact factor: 3.210
Authors: Arjan Roest; Bart van Bets; Philippe G Jorens; Ingrid Baar; Joost Weyler; Rudy Mercelis Journal: Neurocrit Care Date: 2009-01-07 Impact factor: 3.210
Authors: Santosh K Sanganalmath; Purva Gopal; John R Parker; Richard K Downs; Joseph C Parker; Buddhadeb Dawn Journal: Mol Cell Biochem Date: 2016-11-28 Impact factor: 3.396
Authors: J P Nolan; C D Deakin; J Soar; B W Böttiger; G Smith; M Baubin; B Dirks; V Wenzel Journal: Notf Rett Med Date: 2006-02-01 Impact factor: 0.826