T L Chow1, V Venu, S P Kwok. 1. Department of Surgery, United Christian Hospital, Kwun Tong, Kowloon, Hong Kong.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: With the advent of fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC), the role of frozen section (FS) in the management of non-toxic thyroid nodules has become uncertain. METHODS: During the period from January 1993 to December 1995, a total of 84 patients have undergone operative treatment for non-toxic thyroid nodules at the United Christian Hospital, Kowloon. The medical records of these patients were studied retrospectively. RESULTS: In the benign group, the diagnostic accuracy of FNAC was 94% and that of FS was 91%. If FNAC reported malignancy, the diagnostic accuracy was 70%. If FS reported malignancy, the report was accurate in 100%. Among the 43 cases reported as benign on FNAC, FS did not alter the surgical management in any case. In 10 cases reported as suspicious on FNAC, FS altered the surgical treatment in one (10%). However, among the 10 cases reported as malignant on FNAC, FS subsequently altered the surgical management in five cases (50%). In three cases of malignancy on FNAC, both FS and the final histopathology report showed benign disease. Hence, FS avoided overtreatment in three patients. CONCLUSION: Frozen section is indicated if pre-operative FNAC of the thyroid nodules suggests malignancy, in order to determine the extent of the operation and to avoid overtreatment of benign disease. However, FS can be omitted if FNAC is reported as benign or suspicious.
BACKGROUND: With the advent of fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC), the role of frozen section (FS) in the management of non-toxic thyroid nodules has become uncertain. METHODS: During the period from January 1993 to December 1995, a total of 84 patients have undergone operative treatment for non-toxic thyroid nodules at the United Christian Hospital, Kowloon. The medical records of these patients were studied retrospectively. RESULTS: In the benign group, the diagnostic accuracy of FNAC was 94% and that of FS was 91%. If FNAC reported malignancy, the diagnostic accuracy was 70%. If FS reported malignancy, the report was accurate in 100%. Among the 43 cases reported as benign on FNAC, FS did not alter the surgical management in any case. In 10 cases reported as suspicious on FNAC, FS altered the surgical treatment in one (10%). However, among the 10 cases reported as malignant on FNAC, FS subsequently altered the surgical management in five cases (50%). In three cases of malignancy on FNAC, both FS and the final histopathology report showed benign disease. Hence, FS avoided overtreatment in three patients. CONCLUSION: Frozen section is indicated if pre-operative FNAC of the thyroid nodules suggests malignancy, in order to determine the extent of the operation and to avoid overtreatment of benign disease. However, FS can be omitted if FNAC is reported as benign or suspicious.
Authors: João Paulo Alves de Almeida; Sergio Dias do Couto Netto; Rafael Pinto da Rocha; Elio G Pfuetzenreiter; Rogério Aparecido Dedivitis Journal: Braz J Otorhinolaryngol Date: 2009 Mar-Apr